Madhura Naranga

Human bonding is a natural virtue. It drives individuals of a society to altruistically sacrifice personal needs, safeties, and time for the good of the others within it. And, as ‘Madhura Narunga’ (Sweet Lemon) suggests, it is best manifested when people are on foreign sands and in dire straits.

The premise is as old as the desert. A sweet girl with nowhere to go illegally takes shelter with a trio of gentlemen with urges. Clichéd, undoubtedly, but open to a lot of possibilities; none of which is explored. The writer announces that he’s going through a creative block very early on. Love happens immediately. And till the half way mark, the four characters idle their time, waiting for the scriptwriter to crack some ideas.

Do not expect to get a sweeping view of Dubai, even though that is where a major part of the story is supposedly set. Most of this play takes place in the three bachelors’ quarters. And what a massive place with a nice courtyard and costly wooden doors it is. Taxi drivers and counter salesmen get paid in gold slabs, or what? You get to see a beach. And at the first opportunity, the romancing boy and girl start running on a hilltop and around trees.

Some of the shots of an actor’s frozen expression are prolonged to create a desired effect. But one wonders if the editor faced a shortage of footage; at times, some of the wide-angle images with three or four characters in the frame last almost up to half a minute. And that’s not the only cinematic crime that V Sajan, who has cut some notable films, is guilty of; he even resorts to gimmickry.

What a waste of three excellent male actors in their prime. Instead of putting them to good use, their dialogues too are drowned by loud music. The girl, a debutant, appears thrilled to have gotten the part; she’s still a little raw, but looks very much the type that is eager to learn. The intended somber tone of the film is achieved by some amount of all-round crying, rolls of hospital bandage, and Kunchacko Boban with a scarred face and an impressive disabled limp.

When fortunes fail, the feeling that comes of being surrounded by people with whom one has shared a happy time can be comforting.

Sugeeth’s slice-of-Malayali-life-in-the-Gulf romantic drama has him cozily united with the scriptwriter, cinematographer, editor, a lyric writer, and two lead actors of his roaring debut, ‘Ordinary’. What they lacked, surely, is a clever script doctor who would have taken one quick look at the writing and said: Look, all this phony coincidence and melodrama is fine, but where’s the gravitas?

Categories
Film Reviews

Dalton L is a film critic/essayist. He has served on the music jury of MG university, and the film jury of ALIIFF. And has co-authored a book on cinema. In addition to being a writer, he is also a prolific cameraman with over ten years of experience as a documenter of reality, and has briefly captured in moving images a variety of performers ranging from Pt. Jasraj and Trilok Gurtu to America, Shaggy, Enrique Iglesias, Jethro Tull, Uriah Heap, and Dire Straits. He is presently setting up a film studio, ‘House of Illusions’, and shooting five cinematic essays. He is on the verge too of editing-publishing a film magazine, ‘Illusions’.

No comment

Leave a reply

Log in using below social networks to join the discussion
Site Archives

Related by

  • Ermano Olmi is a filmmaker who remained true to the tenets of neo-realism (as defined by their ideologue Zavattini) long after the more celebrated adherents to the creed –...
  • The late Krzysztof Kieslowski was one of the most overrated of European filmmakers and few films demonstrate the drawbacks in his approach more than The Double Life of Veronique (1991), regarded...
  • Talk to Her Writer-Director: Pedro Almodóvar Stars: Javier Cámara, Darío Grandinetti, Leonor Watling   The story of Talk to Her does not need retelling – especially since it has...
  • The Long Goodbye Director: Robert Altman Writers: Leigh Brackett, Raymond Chandler Stars: Elliott Gould, Nina van Pallandt, Sterling Hayden Robert Altman’s The Long Goodbye (1973) – based on a novel of...